Monday, March 2, 2009

Madness

Obviously madness plays a very large part in Shakespeare's play Hamlet, however the madness that pervades throughout both the play and the characters isn't all the same.  First we have the guards, the men who see the ghost first.  Since ghosts are more a figment of the imagination than an actual thing, this is the first place we see madness.  This scene is  very important for setting the stage for the rest of the play.  This scene introduces the madness that will be seen throughout the play.  The next place we see madness is when Hamlet talks to the ghost.  Again we have a character essentially talking to himself.  This scene sets the stage for Hamlet's future madness, although Hamlet decides that he will pretend to be mad, there is a certain level of real madness that Hamlet experiences.  Hamlet's madness, like Ophelia's stems not from a biological predisposition, but rather from grief.  The loss of his father and the quick remarriage by his mother causes Hamlet much grief.  Instead of using typical outlets for that grief Hamlet begins to hallucinate, he convinces himself that in order to avenge his father he must pretend to be crazy, he must bring hardship to his life and to the lives of those around him.  Furthermore, his craziness leads him to place blame, while the blame isn't baseless, it's not entirely proved either.  Hamlet's craziness leads to anger, frustration, and the need for revenge.  The typical trio for men.  On the other side of the spectrum we have Ophelia's madness.  Her madness stems from grief as well.  However, instead of looking to avenge her father, her craziness results in suicide.  Ophelia and Hamlet's craziness both stem from grief and their end result, whether intentional or unintentional, brings pain to those around them.  
I believe that Shakespeare used his character's craziness to provide insight into both their character's minds as well as gender differences that are seen in everything.  The fact that he had the two lovers Ophelia and Hamlet go mad shows the two sides of craziness, the violent and conniving side, as well as the depressed and suicidal side.  I believe Shakespeare's overall theme was grief, but the way that he chose to represent his theme was through madness.  Hamlet, was a way for Shakespeare to explore grief to it's fullest extent.  

5 comments:

Joshua Zieve said...

J,
I agree that the way ghosts are a figment of the imagination would lead one to consider the witness as crazy, but the fact of the matter is that multiple people saw the ghost. Could it be that Hamlet's grief led him to conceive the ghost in his mind? Well, to the best of my knowledge, the guards weren't terribly despondent, and they also saw the ghost. Sry, just trying to give you a little food for thought. I feel that with a little refinement, this will yield a terrific essay.

Erin T said...

This is a really great post that could be a kick-butt essay. This play does seem to be all about madness which is then followed by death or the ghost. Josh does point out the interesting fact that all three men did see the ghost.Are they truly mad? or was it actually there?

Sarah Carlson said...

I agree with you that Shakespeare uses grief and madness to connect the reader to the play, yet I'm not entirely sure what S is trying to say about grief itself. Yes, it can cause people to react irrationally, but perhaps he is also trying to show that every person is mad to some degree. I'd be interested to read your essay and see what you have to say.

Kirk said...

I'd have to agree with Josh that the ghost isn't actually a figment of the imagination, after-all it was created in a time when such things were indeed very real to everyone. And to have all three men see the ghost would be a bit over-reaching for madness. Either way the ghost does nothing but reveal the truth and begin Hamlet's journey of revenge. Hamlet's madness however is something to look into. Possibly his speech on existence "to be or not to be..." could be used. Or the way Ophelia sings - maybe the way Hamlet says he loves her when she's being buried, and how does his madness appear at the end of the story, as true madness, or as a culmination of his revenge?

dogs down under said...

Q..you made some lovely points. I agree with you and Josh that the ghosts are figments of the imaginations. The whole dilemma of the justification of insanity is presented throughout the play. I believe that the insanity of Hamlet and Ophelia is justified...ooohh i'm gonna write my essay on that, ya i shall do that.