Monday, September 8, 2008

Lobo's Post #1

Jane Eyre is an amazing book. I must say that it is even better the second time through. Lots of interesting connections I am making that I didn’t catch the first time. The one big thing that stood out to me in the first 130 pages was Helen Burns. This time I can see how much of an effect she had on Jane. Helen’s subtle nature, submissive doctrine, and the scope of her knowledge inspire and motivate Jane. Helen’s influence becomes central to Jane’s personality later on. When Helen died in Jane's arms it had to have been a great shock, one strong enough to deeply implant the memory of the way she conversed to those she respected. In fact the Latin quote which adorns Helen's tombstone "Resurgam - I shall rise again" foreshadows Jane's adaptation of Helen's subtle manners, and the religious strength shown in her dieing speech, which comes largely into play later in the book.

Another thing I think affected Jane greatly was seeing the difference in how the teachers treated the students. Looking at the difference between Miss Scatcherd's treatment of Helen, and how Miss Temple dealt with Mr. Brocklehurst's telling of Jane's character shaped Jane and gave her a stong idea of how she wanted to act as a teacher.

And thats my little spiel.

2 comments:

AJ said...

Good insight, but try not to give anything away next time

David Lavender said...

Some have said that "real" reading is "re-reading" (just as the most important writing is revision). I'm glad you're finding this book even more compelling the second time through. Indeed, it's just the sort of novel that warrants a second read; while the surprises no longer surprise, you are able to see how hints of what's to come are in fact planted throughout the early sections of the novel.